Charter members
Founding meeting was held on November 27, 1923 in the Henry Club Auditorium. Two officers and thirty-three members recorded as present.
Officers
- Charles I. Allen — Chairman
- Patrick J. Donnely — Secretary
Members present
- George Bennett
- Oscar J. Brentnall
- Charles Burroughs
- James Callaghan
- Frank Conklin
- William Decker
- Stewart Douglas
- Andrew Doyle
- Michael Doyle
- W. S. Fitz-Randolph
- Irving Gannon
- Charles Gilcrest
- Mallick Gillchrist
- Frank Heddy
- Muriel Heddy
- Edwin Higinson
- William E. Kelly
- John Kortright
- A. J. Leemon
- Sutherland Lent
- Albert Mather
- James Miele
- J. Nichols
- Edwin E. Symons
- A. B. Taylor
- Arthur Taylor
- Carlton Waldron
- George Waldron
- Stanley Waldron
- E. J. Ward
- Daniel Whitmore
- George Whriteneur
- Mac G. Wooldock
Ex-Chiefs
- Matthew Swanson(2023–2026) · 43rd Chief
- Matthew Stritmater(2020–2023) · 42nd Chief
- Christopher Morse(2017–2020) · 41st Chief
- Joseph A. Vega(2014–2017) · 40th Chief
- Aniello Vacchiano(2011–2014) · 39th Chief
- Kevin Hartnett(2008–2011) · 38th Chief
- John Johnston(2005–2008) · 37th Chief
- John Bonkoski(2002–2005) · 36th Chief
- Michael Arone, Jr.(2000–2002) · 35th Chief
- Richard Manning(1997–2000) · 34th Chief
- Anthony Massaro(1994–1997) · 33rd Chief
- Peter Barba(1993–1994) · 32nd Chief
- Arnold Reif(1990–1992) · 31st Chief
- Tom Buckley, Jr.(1988–1990) · 30th Chief
- Dave Wilcox(1987–1988) · 29th Chief
- Michael Yorke(1984–1986) · 28th Chief
- Louis Martin(1982–1984) · 27th Chief
- John Froland, Sr.(1981–1982) · 26th Chief
- Robert Stritmater(1979–1981) · 25th Chief
- William Ward(1977–1979) · 24th Chief
- Andrew Gulick(1975–1977) · 23rd Chief
- William McGrady(1973–1975) · 22nd Chief
- Francis Parker(1971–1973) · 21st Chief
- James Ventola(1969–1971) · 20th Chief
- George Heller(1967–1969) · 19th Chief
- Gilmore Lewis(1967) · 18th Chief
- Frank Palazzone(1965–1967) · 17th Chief
- Charles Remo(1963–1965) · 16th Chief
- John Babcook(1962–1963) · 15th Chief
- George McDonnell(1960–1962) · 14th Chief
- Gregorio Gomez(1958–1960) · 13th Chief
- Alexander Massaro(1956–1958) · 12th Chief
- Joseph Miele(1951–1956) · 11th Chief
- Edwin Higinison, Jr.(1951–1952) · 10th Chief
- Thomas Bollato, Sr.(1949–1951) · 9th Chief
- Walter Winters(1947–1948) · 8th Chief
- William Schmarge, Jr.(1946–1948) · 7th Chief
- Fred Storms(1944–1946) · 6th Chief
- James DeGraw(1943–1944) · 5th Chief
- Fred Storms(1941–1943) · 4th Chief
- George Russell, Sr.(1939–1941) · 3rd Chief
- Firma Moffatt(1931–1939) · 2nd Chief
- Frank Conklin(1931) · 1st Chief
Past Presidents
- John Durkin(2015–2023)
- Joseph Hardiman(2008–2015)
- John Bonkoski(2005–2008)
- Michael Yorke(2002–2005)
- Anthony Massaro(2000–2002)
- Peter Barba(1996–2000)
- Thomas Buckley(1994–1996)
- Christopher Lynch(1992–1994)
- Louis LaMendola(1990–1992)
- Michael Yorke(1986–1990)
- Lewis Sutherland(1985–1986)
- Patrick McDonnell(1984–1985)
- Arnold Reif(1982–1984)
- Louis LaMendola
- Robert Drury
- Robert Spohler
- James Izzo
- William Conklin
- John Izzo
- Howard Schmarge
- Forrest Waldron
- William Schmarge, Jr.
- Edwin Higinson, Sr.
- Walter Winters
- Fred Storms
- Ellsworth Boston
- John Douglas
- Charles Allen
Archives
Photo albums, clippings, and scanned documents can be linked from this section as they become available.